Sawyer County Circuit Court Judge Monica Isham has threatened to suspend court proceedings in her branch unless the state provides guidance on handling federal immigration agents in courtrooms. Her stance follows the April 2025 arrest of Milwaukee County Judge Hannah Dugan, charged with aiding an immigrant in evading ICE. In an email to judicial colleagues, Isham expressed concerns about judicial safety and independence, highlighting the need for clear protocols.

Background on Isham’s Position

Isham, the first woman and Native American elected to Sawyer County’s bench, stated that the lack of state support leaves judges vulnerable. She emphasized protecting due process in her courtroom, raising concerns about federal immigration enforcement practices. Isham requested formal guidance by the Judicial District 10 meeting on May 9, 2025, to address these issues.

Legislative Reactions

State Senator Romaine Quinn and Representative Chanz Green criticized Isham’s threat, arguing it could disrupt justice for Sawyer County residents. They suggested resignation if she follows through, stressing the importance of judicial duties. Their comments reflect broader tensions over balancing local and federal authority.

Broader Context

Dugan’s arrest has intensified debates over immigration enforcement in Wisconsin courts. Republican lawmakers recently urged Governor Tony Evers to rescind a memo discouraging state employees from cooperating with ICE without a judicial warrant, citing conflicts with federal law. Meanwhile, Milwaukee County Chief Judge Carl Ashley is developing a policy to address ICE activities in courthouses.

Implications

Isham’s threat highlights the need for standardized protocols to navigate federal-state interactions in courtrooms. The outcome could affect judicial operations and public trust in Wisconsin’s legal system, particularly in rural areas like Sawyer County.